Germany considers a more active role

Germany considers a more active role http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-30004990

Advertisements
Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

World War One at Home: John Logie Baird and the undersock

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-29847206

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Crowds ignore Tower of London poppy garden Tube warning

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-29861969

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The Historian and the Arts/or the ‘Temporal Engineer’

I have been thinking about writing this post for some time. But I caution you the avid reader, just because I have devoted considerable thought to something does not mean I have advanced it thoroughly!

You have been warned!

This post is, what I would view as the first in a series, concerning the historian in the modern era. Recently I have participated in a number of media projects which have used a historical basis to convey information to the public. The first was a television based genealogy programme, the second a play.

Both sets of people were incredibly pleasant to deal with (probably not always the case!) and both seemed to take my concerns regarding factual accuracy at face value. But dare I say without fully understanding why I was so concerned about it. The journalist can print/publish a retraction should something they say be factually incorrect. However the historian has a slightly larger concern. If a statement in the present is wrong, then some recent  memories may be changed; they may be more malleable and can be changed again without upsetting a narrative thread massively.

However if the historian errs, then the past is altered, sometimes with long lasting consequences. These consequences (or ripples if you will) have a ‘knock on’ effect forward in time, which by the very nature of linear based timelines, MUST displace thought and conclusions based on now altered facts and arguments. Therefore logically a new narrative must take the place of the old one, resulting in a ‘new’ history being written, a new narrative being accepted, being taught in schools to a new generation.

This is nothing less than the social engineering of an entire generation.

And the inaccurate historian can create havoc.

The reason why historians stick to facts, the reason they must insist on correctness and accuracy of not only their sources but also their argumentation and reasoning is directly related to the above facts. Without accuracy and dedication to accuracy, then the historian runs role risk of tacitly supporting the construction of a flawed narrative, which may alter the perception of the past in ways which often last far beyond the instigating portrayal, often in the media.

Two good examples would be the film MICHAEL COLLINS and the debate surrounding the scholarship of the late Peter Hart. You’d be genuinely surprised to discover jist how many people thought the British fired at the GPO in the manner depicted in the Neil Jordan film, instead of sniping from the ends of Sackville Street! Or those who STILL believe that the Auxiliaries drove an armoured car onto the pitch in Croke Park to initiate the massacre!

The (ongoing, posthumous) debate concerning Dr. Hart’s secret sources and the alleged false surrender at the Kilmichael Ambush has generated (to paraphrase) “more heat than light.” The withholding of his attributable witness sources and allegations ranging from academic fraud, to stupidity, to outright lying and deception have irreparably damaged the debate surrounding the incident. In this instance Dr. Hart must shoulder a significant portion of the blame, as it was his initial allegations rubbishing the claims of a ‘false surre’ that ignited matters. What he should  have done was secure an impartial third-party to review his unmasked sources and then to vouch for them should they be credible. But alas, poor scholarship and not a small measure of stubborness led to entrenchment and now we may never truly learn of his reasoning.

This, disastrous debacle, is a very solid reason why the dreaded R-word has been received so poorly in Irish Historical scholarship; in truth all ‘new’ history is revisionist in natureand content, if not aggressively so in outlook.

But I digress.

When engaged on a project the historian must ALWAYS endeavour to put factual accuracy to the forefront and should it be necessary, they must be willing to defend that accuracy with dogged determination and righteousness. This stubborness (of which the author has a personal and genetic stockpile) must not be aimed at sheer awkwardness (less the “Ulster Says No”), but rather should be couched in terms appealing to commonsense and should convey a genuine, sincere and professional desire to uphold an accurate, reasoned and logical truth.

While sometimes this approach will fall on understanding, but ultimately unsympathetic (not meant in the negative sense!) ears,  nonetheless every reasoned effort must be made, within the framework of the project, to assure accuracy. Where accuracy is compromised, often in the case of artistic licence, such deviation from the truth must be clearly acknowledged, preferably audibly or in writing! This is to protect both the audience and the historian and also to indemnify the latter from persons claiming that historical accuracy has indeed been compromised.

There’s no business like show business, especially not for a ‘Temporal Engineer’/Historian!

Posted in Commemoration, Conflict, Historian, Ireland, Memory, Revisionism | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Bunker busting under London?

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-29566275

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

U-boat found with ship it sank

U-boat found with ship it sank http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-29721118

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

How the British financed Napoleon’s return to power!

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-29643065

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The forgotten women of the ‘war in the East’

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-29665232

Posted in Britain, Empire, Memory, Second World War, women | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Limerick’s Military & Logistical Heritage

image

Limerick, my own adopted city, has a proud and even some would say defiant history of involvement in military affairs. From the Williamite siege of the city, to this year’s 75th anniversary celebration of the Irish Army’s Limerick based 12th Battalion home (in the aftermath of the Irish Civil War), the Treaty City has a wide swathe of experiences related to the World of Warfare.

image

image

But not everything of a military mindset is directly related to the business end of a soldiers job. Quite a significant amount of military logistical history can be traced to Limerick; from the havoc that manifested itself after the Patrick Sarsfield destroyed the Williamite army’s siege train, Limerick has provided a series of case studies for the military historian.

image

Geographically speaking, Limerick has a number of unique advantages. It is uniquely situated in Ireland at the furthest possible fording point on the mighty River Shannon, which by the time it reaches Limerick, has become a tidal estuary. This allows the ancient King Johns Castle an unrivalled position in terms of defence and control over the nodal bridiging points and trade. As the song goes ‘There is an Isle/A bonny isle/Which stretches forth/Proudly against the Sea.’

image

It was this trade which made (and still makes) Limerick a vitally important logistical and transportational hub. It is located at the Western edge of the ‘Golden Vale’, a geographical area in the Mid-Western sub-region of Ireland, famed for producing some of the beat bacon, cheese, dairy and beef products in the world. Limerick as the largest and nearest accessible natural port, facing the Atlantic ocean was a natural choice for a transhipment point. Indeed in the 19th century the city acquired the moniker ‘Pig Town’, such was the volume of its pork related exports.

image

Another key actor in this supply chain was the Tait Military Clothing Factory. The factory, located on Lord Edward Street a stones throw from the gates of the city’s Sarsfield Barracks (formerly the New Barracks), was a magnificent example of a military clothing purveyor during the 19th and early 20th centuries. The firm supplied many continental forces (including the British Army during the Great War, whose centenary we currently commemorate). More interestingly perhaps is the fact that Tait’s also supplied the Southern Confederate forces during the American Civil War. The eponymous ‘Tait Jacket’ was produced for the officer corps, in Limerick.

image

image

From their factory (portions of which still stand and are being redeveloped), the Tait’s supplied materials to the both Union and Confederate belligerents during their conflict.

image

image

image

image

image

An amusing anecdote is still told in Limerick of a Chandler who was contracted to supply the Confederates with tents, pegs and ropes. The merchant loaded a number of ships with the requested goods and despatched them. However in a manner similar to the destruction of the British Army’s Pals Battalions half a century later, disaster befell the convoy; one of the ships sank. This resulted in the ropes and pegs arriving unscathed on one ship and all of the tent canvas headed toward the briney deep!

Posted in Britain, Conflict, Empire, First World War, Ireland, Irish Defence Forces, Logistics, Oglaigh na hEireann, Organisational History | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 5 Comments

The Disappeared: Human remains found in search for Brendan Megraw

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-29444256

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

The Other Great War 1918+

How in a single year did life expectancy in the US dropped by 12 years? http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-29541235

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Aids: Origin of pandemic ‘was 1920s Kinshasa’

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-29442642

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Romancing rebellion: the culture that spawned the Irish rebels of Easter 1916

http://www.newstatesman.com/culture/2014/10/romancing-rebellion-culture-spawned-irish-rebels-easter-1916-b

The review begs the question was the real fight the revolution of the soul?

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Boots on the Ground

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-magazine-monitor-29413429

In the latter years of the Twentieth Century, after the Cold War had come to an end and the thaw that had emerged a new concept was explored in Europe. It was born out of several key concepts and constraints. The budgetary and logistical nightmares of maintaining hundreds of thousands of men, women and materiél almost indefinitely in theatre, as was needed in Cold War Europe led to the evolution of a new concept, which was in effect an old concept with some new window dressing.

Rapid Reaction forces, expeditionary warfare units, Quick Response Forces all names given to military forces which were supposed to be able to remain on suspended readiness for months at a time and then be able to deploy, anywhere on the planet and be fully capable of intervention in a crisis in short order.

At least that was the theory. Now in terms of the recent Russo-Ukranian crisis in the Crimean and Donetsk regions and the ongoing Islamic State slaughter across whole swathes of the Syrian and Iraqi countrysides, it appears that Quick Reaction Forces have fallen out of political favour. American, British and Australian political leaders have all signalled their willingness to engage in unlimited airstrikes against the quasi state (and any entity controlling that massive swathe of
real estate when compared with the actual Iraqi and Syrian governments must be recognised as a serious actor and not denigrated by the juvenile moniker ‘so called Islamic State’), yet they refuse to acknowledge the plain reality I’m front of their faces: sooner or later, everything gets settled by the Infantry.

It’s not bravado, nor bombast, not even service snobbery from the air forces toward the sluggish ground pounders. It all boils down to approval ratings. These days polling and approval ratings are the new gold. Government policies are sold to the populace, politicians hang on every bit of polling data to determine how best (their own best, not what’s right necessarily) to proceed. This proceeding then is logically hampered and hobbled by the limitations imposed upon it by the expectations of a (generally) uninformed and uncaring electorate (a significant portion of whom don’t vote anyway).

The unspoken truth, the bête noir of the early 21st century military operations, is simply this; it is necessary to intervene to establish and execute your will and to do this you will need a range of interventions. These will range from the political, to a coordinated policy of airstrikes and interdictions AND culminating in an intervention by infantry forces. The aerial forces may kill the enemy’s ability to make war on you and other actors, but it is your ability to consolidate that projected power, to deny the created vacuum to the enemy which will determine how successful your forces will be in securing their objectives.

Unfortunately for the western political leaders, decades of limited warfare and extremely poor military planning and a lack of potent, coherent leadership have all contributed to an unwillingness to make decisions which should have been normal and logical. Disastrous campaigns in Vietnam, Iraq (Gulf War 2), Afghanistan, etc have destroyed the willpower necessary to put ‘boots on the ground.’ Successful implementation of a coordinated intervention plan worked well in Kosovo and East Timor. In Haiti they failed due to a lack of a coherent follow-up plan (similar to the complete lack of joined-up-thinking and political willpower in Afghanistan).

Russian forces got mauled in Afghanistan (and it took them a long time to emerge from their own Vietnam) and later and continually in Chechnya and Dagestan. Yet in recent months we saw how Russia used proxy warfare and a limited, yet politically reaolute ‘boots-on-the-ground’ strategy to extend the russian hegemonic sphere further east, which may eventually culminate in the creation of a buffer zone against the ever expanding and yet dithering and anachronistic NATO.

In short, in real terms, until the western militaries accept the need to reinforce fancy airstrikes with a steady leavening of either air mobile troops or an expeditionary warfare cadre, then as history has shown us, international intervention will fall flat.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

How Bosnia is helping Cyprus find peace

How Bosnia is helping Cyprus find peace http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-28145649

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

One people, 1,200 sausages

One people, 1,200 sausages http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-29380144

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Zara’s ‘Holocaust uniform’ and other clothing errors

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-magazine-monitor-28944516

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

How Nigeria turned Her Majesty’s prison into a place of pleasure

NigeriaPrisonService

 

The British had quite the habit of exporting convicts to their colonies, sometimes to work in forced labour, sometimes for penal servitude made all the worse by its great distance from loved ones and familiarity. Indeed the word ‘exported’ was coined in this context by British officialdom to describe a convict who had been exiled, usually to the West Indies, or later to Australia. However the British rarely sent building supplies with the convicts and that is where we start today’s blog, in Nigeria.

 

The original building which dated from 1882, was constructed of largely flammable materials (timber and reeds) and was regularly attacked and set on fire by the locals. Incensed by this assault and seeking a more permanent solution to policing woes, the British colonial administrators turned to the humble British Brick. Bricks by their thousand were imported from the British Isles at tremendous expense (more than double the annual expenditure for education) in an effort to construct not only a lasting place of incarceration, but also a symbol of British power; a clear signal to those arsonists that the British were here to stay and were not leaving any time soon.

 

Broad Street Prison (Courtesy of Lagos City Photos)

Broad Street Prison (Courtesy of Lagos City Photos)

 

The prison housed inmates detained by the dreaded and hated colonial gendarmerie, the Hausa force, specifically recruited from Northern Nigeria to effect a disconnect and cultural discord with the native Southern Nigerians. The hangman in the Prison also had to be brought from the north of the country in order to (1) be able to effectively execute his duties and (2) one suspects add a layer of extra fear, the ‘other’ outsiders coming to kill on behalf of the British. Over the years Broad Street Prison housed some men who would become very famous in Nigeria’s independence struggle; the political activist Herbert Macaulay, Trade Unionist Pa Michael Imoudu and the politician Obafemi Awolowo.

 

After independence plans were set in motion to tear down the symbol of colonial oppression, but with the turbulent political climate they were forever stalling. Eventually locals were able to convert it into a garden and a recreational asset for the whole community in Lagos, in a fashion similar to the work of Caesar Manrique in Lanzarote.

 

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-28418685

Posted in Britain, decolonisation, Empire, Insurgency, women | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

World War One: Kenya’s forgotten heroes

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-28836752

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

The WW1 game that’s still popular today

The WW1 game that’s still popular today http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-29050369

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

2.6m historic pictures posted online

2.6m historic pictures posted online http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-28976849

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The odd objects looted from Washington DC in 1814

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-magazine-monitor-28833238

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The odd objects looted from Washington DC in 1814

The odd objects looted from Washington DC in 1814 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-magazine-monitor-28833238

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Irish Home Rule and the First World War: A Video History by Ronan McGreevy

Irish Home Rule and the First World War

 

This fantastic short video introduction to the topic of Irish Home Rule and the impact which the advent of the First World War had on it, is brought to you by Ronan McGreevy. I understand it is the first in a short series on both the conflict and the issues of Irish freedom and self-determination. 

Posted in Britain, Commemoration, Conflict, decolonisation, Empire, First World War, Historiography, Ireland, Memory | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Coonagh had highest death toll in World War I

http://www.solimerick.com/news/1205/coonagh-had-highest-death-toll-i

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Restoring Cork’s National Monument

When time stands still – restoring the national monument
http://www.irishexaminer.com/ireland/when-time-stands-still-restoring-the-national-monument-281964.html?utm_source=androidapp&utm_medium=share&utm_campaign=sharebutton

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Uncivilised Actions in a Civil War

Clashmealcon Memorial

Clashmealcon Memorial

With the world’s rather limited attention span at present being directed at the horrors that are the civil wars in both Ukraine and Iraq/Syria, one could almost be forgiven for thinking that the Irish road to eventual independence came with a rather limited human cost, that we were spared the worst excesses of zealotry and that the blight of internecine conflict never troubled us.

 

But unfortunately you would be wrong. So very, very wrong.

 

wpid-dsc_0035.jpg

 

The Irish civil war shocked even those most jaded by the long campaign waged for independence in Ireland. The Ireland of the 1913 Lockout, the Somme, the Easter Rising, the Tan War and Bloody Sunday, did not leave the butcher’s bill lacking when it came to a post-Treaty schism. The events of 1922-1923 are shadowy in aspect, they are rarely brought into the full light of day; partly one suspects because of the shameful nature of ‘falling’ from the heroic epic of fighting the ‘invader’ to fighting one’s brethren and partly owing to the squalid, hateful nature of the conflict itself. During this period men and women who had pledged their lives to something better, to something greater than themselves, to an ideal, a hope, those same men and women fell like angels and contested the scraps on a barren earth.

 

National Army soldiers escort an IRA prisoner during the Civil War in Munster

National Army soldiers escort an IRA prisoner during the Civil War in Munster

 

The Irish Civil War saw the deaths of many; some estimates put the losses at between one and four-thousand souls. Whilst the republicans managed to inflict about eight to nine-hundred casualties on the nascent Free State forces, they received far higher casualties themselves; needless to say, the civilian population also suffered high casualties. Although the hostlities were sread throughout the island, they were concentrated in the South and West. The new National Army was able to bring overwhelming forces to bear on the beleagured rebels and eventually, after the loss of the major towns and the Fall of Limerick and Cork, the Anti-Treaty IRA were forced to adopt their tried and tested Guerrilla Warfare strategy. During the Winter of 1922, the IRA’s conventional structure had been destroyed and men had grouped together in units of under ten, living together in safe-houses.

 

Clashmealcon Safe House

Clashmealcon Safe House

 

Also during the Winter of 1922, the Free State, shorn of its leadership of Michael Collins and Arthur Griffith in the previous months, was left to prosecute the war as best it could. The Provisional Government authorised the execution of Anti-Treaty prisoners. With the die cast, the executions of over seventy Anti-Treatites soon led to assassinations, including that of TD Seán Hales.

 

Memorial Plaque on the Safe House wall

Memorial Plaque on the Safe House wall

 

And assassinations swiftly led to Free State atrocities like the Ballyseedy, where nine captured republicans were tied to a landmine, which was then detonated, killing eight and allowing only one to escape. Massacres such as this ignited the public consciousness in condemnation of this period in our history. The revulsion shared by many concerning this period had led to a ‘blacking-out’ of it from the national consciousness, until its emergence in recent decades.

 

Clashmealcon memorial

Clashmealcon memorial

 

One event which generated great sadness in recent years was the massacre at the small North Kerry townland of Clashmealcon. During the Free State’s Spring offensive in 1923, Jim McGrath was captured and was tortured extensively at Ballymullen Barracks, Tralee. Jim apparently revealed the location of a secret IRA hideout, Dunworth’s Cave, which he believed had been unoccupied for some time. Unfortunately when the National Army soldiers brought him to show them where the cave was, he came across a small cadre of IRA men hiding out there, including his brother Thomas (Tom) McGrath. After an exchange of gunfire, in which two soldiers were killed, the Free Staters decided to starve the IRA out of the cave and camped out around the mouth of the cave. A number of the men, including Tommy O’Shea, decided to try and swim from the cave that night, but they were drowned in the attempt.

 

wpid-dsc_0046.jpg

 

The IRA leader, Timothy Lyons offered himself in surrender in order to save his men. While he was being lifted up on a rope out of the cave, the rope snapped and he fell to the cave floor. There, despite his grave injuries, the soldiers ‘riddled’ him with bullets. In latter years great doubt has been cast on whether the rope actually snapped, instead theories have been put forth that Lyons was dropped to his death and effectively murdered by the soldiers keen to avenge the deaths of their comrades earlier in the siege. Once the rest of the men had surrendered (Rudge Hathaway, an ex-British soldier who had deserted to fight for the IRA, James McErney and Edward Greaney), they were escorted to Ballymullen Barracks, where they were executed on the 25th of April, 1923.

 

wpid-dsc_0040.jpg

Celtic Cross memorial near Dunworth’s Cave

 

 

 

 

wpid-dsc_0041.jpg

inscription on Celtic Cross memorial

 

And the story abided in folk memory for generations until the local community in North Kerry  were able to come together and erect a monument to the fallen men, both at the site of their house (some three-hundred metres from the cave) and nearer the cave itself. Photographs of both monuments are attached to this article.

 

wpid-dsc_0037.jpg

Commemorative Plaque beside memorial

 

Path to Dunworth's Cave

Path to Dunworth’s Cave

 

Whatever their actions, may they finally rest in peace.

 

Directions from Ballymullen, Tralee, Co. Kerry to Clashmealcon War memorial.

https://www.google.ie/maps/dir/Ballymullen+Army+HQ/Unnamed+Rd,+Co.+Kerry/@52.3983887,-9.7010705,10z/am=t/data=!4m14!4m13!1m5!1m1!1s0x4845359d9d79b56d:0xf2a1cedad4995133!2m2!1d-9.692012!2d52.26289!1m5!1m1!1s0x485ac87a029f0c03:0x46bb377ab6b24ee8!2m2!1d-9.7402263!2d52.4676641!3e0

Posted in 1916, Commemoration, Conflict, decolonisation, Ireland, Irish Defence Forces, Memory, Oglaigh na hEireann, revolutionary | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Mullinahone RIC station

http://humphrysfamilytree.com/Cashel/mullinahone.station.html

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Documentary reveals 2m Irish men died fighting for Britain

http://www.irishexaminer.com/ireland/documentary-reveals-2m-irish-men-died-fighting-for-britain-264038.html?utm_source=androidapp&utm_medium=share&utm_campaign=sharebutton

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | Leave a comment

Israeli plaque removed after attacks

Historical Place Marker for the birthplace of Chaim Herzog

Historical Place Marker for the birthplace of Chaim Herzog

 

Israeli plaque removed after attacks http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-28766816

 

Belfast is a funny city.

 

I mean in 90% of Northern Ireland (and by extension, Ulster), the Orange Order organises reasonably decent commemorative events for Loyal men and women to commemorate the Battle of the Boyne (although there is some dispute over whether or not it was really a as decisive a victory as it has been claimed…but I digress). But in Belfast, with its hardened attitudes, parades are incredibly contentious issues.

 

So when nationalists sought to commemorate the sacrifice of the hunger-strikers recently, the loyalist community had no desire to allow such a march to pass unscathed. And so followed PSNI riot gear, armoured cars, fireworks, etc etc.

 

But what is most interesting about all of this is the fact that at these parades, non-traditional flags have started to be flown. At first it was the nationalists supporting Gaza and the Palestinians as they identified with the minority community being subjugated by the larger and more powerful Israeli state. But this in turn led to the Loyalist community marching with their own support flag, that of the Star of David, the national flag of Israel.

 

Now one must ask oneself, do Loyalists truly believe in the Right of Return, in the deep seated need to pray at the Wailing Wall, or the rights of the settlers in Kibbutzen? They probably don’t, but they do know that the Palestinians don’t like the Israelis and anything the Nationalists like, the Loyalists must hate in turn.

 

One wonders what they both think of regarding oxygen, food and water…..the dreaded compromise surely!

 

So with this new found pro-and-anti-Semitism sweeping Belfast, it comes as little surprise that the thugs (those who can read at least) have targeted any public support for the state of Israel, even any acknowledgement of its existence, however tenuous. Regrettably this has even come to include blue heritage disks denoting the birthplace of historical figures like the late Chaim Herzog, Israeli President, whose family was born at Cliftonpark  Avenue, Belfast in  1918 and who emmigrated to Israel at a young age. Despite Herzog’s record of unfailing support for the state of Israel (right or wrong), surely a place-marker to a man long dead (and even longer departed from his birthplace) should remain above matters.

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Antarctica mission launch re-enacted

Antarctica mission launch re-enacted http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-devon-28702267

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

The ‘lost’ poetry of World War One

The ‘lost’ poetry of World War One http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-28705819

Britain and the Western World was preparing for the Great War for well over thirty years, so it comes as little surprise that the media was ready to play it’s part. The day after the war was ‘reluctantly’ declared, English newspapers published what was to be the first in a series of poems in praise of extrmem nationalism, jingoistic ideology and ultimately the old adage of ‘Dulce et Decorum est, Pro Patria Mori; it is sweet and honourable to die for one’s country!’

The Vigil by Sir Henry Newbolt was carried in The Times

England: where the sacred flame

Burns before the inmost shrine,

Where the lips that love thy name

Consecrate their hopes and thine,

Where the banners of thy dead

Weave their shadows overhead.

Watch beside thine arms to-night,

Pray that God defend the Right.

Posted in Art, Britain, First World War, France, Memory | Tagged , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Five US generals killed in action

Five US generals killed in action http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-28669943

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Robinson Crusoe Fitzgerald Kennedy

ID Card of Lt (JG) JOhn F Kennedy, USNR (www.bbc.co.uk)

ID Card of Lt (JG) JOhn F Kennedy, USNR (www.bbc.co.uk)

The men who saved JFK’s life http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-28644830

  Most articles on President John Fitzgerald Kennedy tend to focus on the man’s assassination in Dallas in 1963; few if any recall that the man known to the world as JFK had actually lived a rather rich, if short life up until that point in time. Born into the illustrious Kennedy clan from Massachusetts (whose ancestors hailed from Dunganstown, County Wexford in Ireland), John and his brother Bobby were destined to reach high office, in a fashion not dissimilar to their father, Joe Kennedy. John started the war as an Ensign with a desk job, but later graduated to the position of Lieutenant (Junior Grade) and held command of a Motor Torpedo Boat, PT-101.

JFK on PT-101 (www.bbc.co.uk)

JFK on PT-101 (www.bbc.co.uk)

While there, and after participating in a number of previous actions, PT-101 was rammed and sunk by the Japanese destroyer Amagiri, on the 2nd of August 1943. The survivors clung to wreckage and eventually were able to swim to a nearby island. JFK towed his badly-burned senior enlisted mate, Patrick McMahon to safety by clenching his life vest strap between his teeth.

_76759113_eroni&sorephotoshop

Eroni Kumana (www.bbc.co.uk)

There they waited until two natives, Eroni Kumana and Biuku Gasa, arrived by canoe and were able to take a message, scratched into a coconut to the naval authorities to arrange for a rescue. The message simply read;

NAURO ISL

COMMANDER… NATIVE KNOWS POS’IT…

HE CAN PILOT… 11 ALIVE

NEED SMALL BOAT… KENNEDY

 

(www.bbc.co.uk)

(www.bbc.co.uk)

JFK later had the coconut shell made into a paperweight which he kept on his Oval Office desk, ironically made from the timbers of another sunken ship, the HMS Resolute. Kumana sadly passed away at the age of 93, on Saturday 2nd of August.

Posted in 20th century, Memory, Second World War, US Armed Forces | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

A Positive-Negative Development

 

Father Francis Browne

Father Francis Browne

 

Nationwide Photographic Programme

 

Last Wednesday night’s Nationwide special brought to us by the Irish national broadcaster, rté, showcased a series of photographs which detail the lives lived by Irishmen and women who volunteered to serve in the Great War. This is the fascinating story of a Jesuit, Father Eddie O’Donnell, who was clearing up a room in the Provincial House in Dublin, where he came across a trunk containing thousands of old negatives relating to the First World War. 

 

Father Browne with one of his beloved cameras

Father Browne with one of his beloved cameras

 

Father Francis Browne, better known as the priest who documented the Titanic and also Irish life in the early years of the twentieth century, had volunteered for service as a chaplain during the War and was posted to the 1st Battalion, Irish Guards. Frank’s service took him to the Western Front, where he was wounded on five occasions and rather badly gassed. He returned from the War the most decorated Catholic chaplain of the conflict. There he was able to take advantage of his affable personality and the initially cautious deference accorded to both a chaplain and also a photographer, to document his environment and his men around him in both the trenches and out of them. 

 

Browne self-portrait

Browne self-portrait

Browne later was seconded to the Royal Dublin Fusiliers, where he took part in the Passchendaelle with the famous Father Willie Doyle and his lucky Dug Out. Unfortunately Doyle was to be killed during that battle, Browne being given a handwritten note informing him of the loss, with ‘BROWNE’ scratched out and ‘DOYLE’ written above it, so confusing were those heady days on the Western Front. Although in newly independent Ireland, the war services of thousands of Irishmen who had volunteered to aid ‘small-nations’ like Belgium were put to one side of the historical narrative of the new country, those whom he served with never forgot Browne’s contribution; the British awarded him the Military Cross, the Belgians the Croix de Guerre and the French their Croix de Guerre with Palm.

 

Father Frank Browne’s story can be read in the book expertly written by Father Eddie O’Donnell, S.J.  Father Browne’s First World War or viewed on rté’s media player for the next few weeks Nationwide Photographic Programme.

9781910248027-267x322

 

 

Posted in Britain, Commemoration, First World War, France, Ireland, Memory | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Comdt Padraic Kennedy

Comdt Padraic Kennedy speaks on his role as OiC (Office in Charge) of the Military Archives, the www.bureauofmilitaryhistory.ie website and the release of the Military Witness Statements which ushered in the Long Decade of Commemoration.

Posted in 1916, 20th century, Archive, Britain, Commemoration, First World War, Historiography, Insurgency, Ireland, Irish Defence Forces, Oglaigh na hEireann, revolutionary, Royal Irish Constabulary | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

World War One battlefields 100 years on

World War One battlefields 100 years on http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/in-pictures-28461026

Posted in Britain, Commemoration, First World War, France, Memory, United States | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Beyond the Balmoral: Major Claude Raul Champion de Crespigny

 

http://www.bbc.co.uk/arts/yourpaintings/paintings/major-claude-raul-champion-de-crespigny-18781941-5th-bt-49166

 

A portrait of a fine gentleman and Auxiliary Policeman, Claude Raul Champion de Crespigny, 5th Baronet.

 

This family had an interesting time of it. From the end of the Second World War, the baronetcy passed three times in as many years along the hereditary lines of succession. In 1910, the heir to the family estate, Claude Champion de Crespigny (presumably the elder brother to Claude Raul/Raoul) committed suicide allegedly after having his heart broken by a married woman; he had been named in her divorce case as a co-respondent. The coroner described that too many heavy falls from Polo and influenza had brought about a state of ‘temporary insanity’ which preceded the early death.

 

Claude Raul became the heir and went first to Ireland where he served as an Auxiliary Officer (Company 2i/c C Coy, Macroom), with the Company that had suffered such depredations at the hands of Tom Barry’s IRA Active Service Unit in Kilmichael.

 

An account of the death of the elder brother may be seen below from the New York Times (20 May 1910).

 

102039750

Posted in Auxiliary Division, Britain, First World War, Royal Irish Constabulary | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Nationwide Once Again

Absolution by father Francis Gleeson before the Battle of Artois with the Munster Fusiliers

Absolution by father Francis Gleeson before the Battle of Artois with the Munster Fusiliers

Last night rté, Ireland’s national television station, broadcast the first of three shows dedicated to the tensions and histories of the men and women who gave their lives in what would become known as the First World War. 

The Regimental Colours of the Connaught Rangers

The Regimental Colours of the Connaught Rangers

The Nationwide programme showcased the three Irish Divisions which fought with the Allies during the conflict on the Western Front and in the Dardanelles Campaign also. The men from the 36th Ulster Division were commemorated along with those from the Royal Munster Fusiliers, the Connaught Rangers and the Royal Dublin Fusiliers. The Connaught Rangers, or The Devil’s Own as they were known, famously refused to follow orders in a mutiny over the aggression shown by the British government in Ireland during the Anglo-Irish War. The spirit of the Munsters was expertly captured in the now famous painting by Fortunino Matania of the General Absolution at on the Rude du Bois, by Father Francis Gleeson. The Dublin Fusiliers took such heavy casualties with the Munsters during the landings at V Beach, Cape Hellas, that they had to form a composite battalion nicknamed the Dubsters

V Beach, the Daradnelles

V Beach, the Daradnelles

The presenter, Mary Kenny, and the researchers for the programme did a really marvelous job and one hopes that future presentations by rté and others will live up to this high standard! The show is available to watch on the rté player for the next 28 days and is fantastic viewing! 

http://www.rte.ie/player/ie/show/10308192/

Posted in 1916, 20th century, Britain, Commemoration, Conflict, Empire, First World War, Ireland, Memory, Northern Ireland | Leave a comment

Last Hiroshima bomb crew member dies

Last Hiroshima bomb crew member dies http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-28548475

Posted in Second World War, United States | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Don’t get your Bat Trunks in a Knot!

                                  Batman's....Trunks

Batman’s….Trunks

 

Follow Me: http://www.tor.com/blogs/2014/07/a-brief-history-of-batmans-trunks!!!

Now normally this site is purely dedicated to Military History and the like, but given how popular last year’s homage to Batman and history was, I’ve decided those of you who have a keen interest in all things Bat-related, deserve a treat!

The publishing house, Tor, has commissioned Mr. Jim Beard to write the following brief history of….you guessed it, Batman’s trunks! Yes Bat-fans, you heard it right the first time, Beard has gone throughout history and has returned to the reader with a chronological look at the Caped Crusader’s undies drawer down through the ages. From the very beginning Batman needed a loin covering, just iike Superman and Tarzan, the enemy of crime chose to pull on what were effectively black hot-pants….who likes short shorts??

As time progressed, Bats settled into a fetching blue number and went through a number of style changes also. But I won’t give too much away! Suffice to say scroll down and prepare to be horrified! Be sure to check this story out with the morning coffee, well worth a read! Though you may never look at the Batman quite the same again! 

Keep scrolling!

All there

All there

*cough, cough*, nice look Bruce….

 

Also be sure to check out JIm’s new book, Gotham City 14 Miles, link to the book at bottom of the linked content!

Posted in 20th century, Pop Art | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Royal Crest at NUI Galway

image

Here are a few pictures which I took some time ago of a disused royal crest carved ‘in the round’ at the National University of Ireland Galway.

image

As you can see from the relief detail and also the lion and unicorn, it definitely suggests an older British connection, possibly even a royal one. Could it have been removed in the post independence period?

image

The sculpture languishes beside a small access road around the rear of the Aula Maxima in the main campus.

image

Rear of Aula Maxima, NUIG, Galway, Ireland

image

Directions from Eyre Square

Posted in Art, Britain, Empire, Ireland, Memory | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

image

Here are a few pictures which I took some time ago of a disused royal crest carved ‘in the round’ at the National University of Ireland Galway.

image

As you can see from the relief detail and also the lion and unicorn, it definitely suggests an older British connection, possibly even a royal one.

image

image

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The RIC (Royal Italian Constabulary)

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-28254297

The carabinieri have served Italy for 200 years in a fashion similar to other gendarmeries. Indeed when one considers matters the similarities between it and the now defunct Royal Irish Constabulary are striking. Neither force attracts recruits from particularly prosperous backgrounds; service is seen as a way to improve ones lot in life. Policemen must not serve in their home district; for almost the first decade they are internal exiles! And the service has extremely rigorous rules concerning the matrimonial complications which men might undergo; wives were seen as an uneccessary distraction and could only be ‘taken on’ by the policeman when they had sufficient resources to support them!

But the similarities do not
end there. Indeed service in both the Italian and Irish forces was seen as respectable and character affirming, a way in which young men could distance themselves from violent anti-state actors and groups such as communists, organised crime and the fenians.

But the police were not without their critics, some claiming that they were heavy handed (both possessed quasi military attributes, the RIC being the sole non-military armed police force in the British Isles, the Carabinieri being a section of the Italian Armed Forces proper). On a lighter note, they also drew attention from caricaturists pens with the constables being portrayed with ridiculous moustaches (there was a conflicting series of regulations concerning their existence) and regularly appearing as dumbfounded brutish figures in periodicals like Punch.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

An Irishman’s Diary on Hubert Gough, an enigmatic general

http://www.irishtimes.com/culture/heritage/an-irishman-s-diary-on-hubert-gough-an-enigmatic-general-1.1858372

Posted in Britain, Conflict, Empire, First World War, France, Ireland, Memory, Northern Ireland, Second World War | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

The Marching Dead

US sends draft notices to 1800s men http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-28268638

zombie.2

 

The agency responsible for maintaining and updating the data which allows the United States government to theoretically the maintain operational capability of conscripting its citizens for military service recently made a slight error.

 

Young men registering for military conscription, New York City, June 5, 1917

Young men registering for military conscription, New York City, June 5, 1917

 

An operative with the Selective Service System, an independent Federal agency with responsibility for maintaining the draft process, inadvertently entered the digit ‘8’ instead of ‘9’ when selecting those who were to be send letters warning them to register with the System. The vast majority of respondents (listed as having been born in 1889, instead of 1989) had died years previously, ironically most of whom had already served in at least one major conflict which the US had been party to in the twentieth century!

 

zombie.1

 

Without maligning veterans, in most Hollywood depictions of mankind battling long dead zombie hordes, the writers probably never imagined the SSS trying to ‘raise’ their own army of the undead!

Posted in 20th century, First World War, Second World War, United States, US Armed Forces | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Trench construction in World War I

Great article here from Diana Overbey on the construction of trenches!

Diana Overbey

When people think of World War I, one of the first images that comes to mind is the trench.  Here’s a look into how these major features were constructed, as well as their impact on the war.

1. When were the trenches in World War I first built?

After the Battle of the Marne in September 1914 (one month after the war truly began), the Germans were pushed back to the River Aisne.  The German commander, General Erich von Falkenhayn, assessed the situation.  Not wanting to lose the territory in France and Belgium Germany had gained, he ordered his army to dig trenches to defend against French and British troops.  The trenches provided necessary protection from artillery shells and machine guns, and gave soldiers a major advantage when warding off a frontal assault.  Realizing that they could not break through these trenches, the British and French soon began digging their own.

View original post 973 more words

Posted in Britain, First World War, France | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Pity the Nations

Krak de Chevaliers in the strategic position guarding the path to the Beqqa Valley, being bombarded by Syrian government forces, March 2014

Krak de Chevaliers in the strategic position guarding the path to the Beqqa Valley, being bombarded by Syrian government forces, March 2014

Art imitates life with alarming regularity, especially in our twenty-first century, but it is rarely seen whereby life returns the favour. Unfortunately the ongoing civil war in Syria is doing just that.

 

Krak des Chevaliers prior to the Syrian Civil War

Krak des Chevaliers prior to the Syrian Civil War

 

The Crusaders’ castle, Krak des Chevaliers has withstood (relatively) unscathed the storms of time and regional geopolitical hardships since it was first raised in the early middle ages. Now in a mere five years it has sustained severe damage to its walls and redoubts. The Krak is located in Homs, the home of some of the fiercest fighting in the Syrian insurgency against the despotic leadership of President Bashar al Asad. The rebels, like countless others before them, readily realised the strategic value of the high ground on which the castle was situated and quickly made the fastness their base of operations in the region.

 

A Rebel fighter hiding in the ruins of the Krak

A Rebel fighter hiding in the ruins of the Krak

 

The Krak, like its more famous cousin Kerak (Al Karak in Arabic) which was brought into the popular consciousness through the Ridley Scott epic Kingdom of Heaven, served as a Crusader citadel and has changed hands multiple times since then. The army of the great muslim leader Saladin was among many that laid siege to the Krak during its lifetime, with the two-thousand strong occupying forces regularly resisting efforts to breach their defences.

 

The recent destruction visited upon the medieval Krak is readily apparent

 

However the Crusaders who survived attacks with trebuchets and ballistae would never have envisaged the terrible effect which modern artillery and aerial bombardment could have on a defensive position. The forces of the Syrian president and rebels have been engaged in a series of offensive and defensive attacks both in and around the fortification, often with the numerically and technologically superior government forces causing the greater damage to the structure, in an attempt to render it useless to the rebels. Mortar shells, MLRS rocket systems, MiG fighter-bombers, tanks, Heavy Machine Guns, Artillery shells and missiles have all been used to reduce the grandeur of Syrian architectural heritage to dusty shreds of its former glory. If the fighting does not end soon, it may be difficult to assess what the sides were fighting for in the first place.

 

A story providing greater detail on the destruction waged upon these priceless sites during the Civil War can be viewed here. Thanks to the BBC for the link. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-28191181

 

UNESCO Krak de Chevaliers http://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1229

 

Al Kerak http://www.alkarak.net/

Posted in Conflict, Insurgency, Memory, Middle East | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Cold war haunting the Israel-Gaza conflict

Libyan GRAD Missile Launcher. Palestinians are using similar weapons against Israel

Libyan GRAD Missile Launcher. Palestinians are using similar weapons against Israel

 

What weapons are being used in the Israel-Gaza conflict http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-28245343

Israel might be a cutting edge weapons producer, but the weapons which it’s enemies deploys against it are a blast (pun unintended) from the past. This short story from the BBC gives a good general overview of the Cold War era missiles being employed in the conflict.

 

Although the majority of these Soviet era weapons are designed to be fired in mass salvoes, like the GRAD and the Upgraded GRAD/WS-1E (NATO designation M1964) system or heavier self propelled mortar systems, they are still surprisingly rugged when fired individually. The article makes a key point and it is worth repeating here; these weapons are not particularly accurate. This method of employment is not what they were initially intended for. They were planned for mass bombardment of the traditional battlespace prior to mechanized/infantry advances. Like other Soviet legacy weapons systems (like the AK family of rifles), it is simple, yet effective. Components can be assembled in small garages/homes/caves with minimal equipment and can be transported through tunnels to Gaza and the West Bank where it is eventually launched. Although the Palestinian splinter forces have also started utilising longer ranged weapons such as the Farj-5 and the Khaibar-1, offering up to 160km range and bringing most of the country into bombardment range,  they are in the minority…for now.

 

In comparison to modern Israeli weapons and defences, it is ironically comparable to David-versus-Goliath.

 

A graphical explanation of IRON DOME and the missile threat. www.defenceforumindia.com

A graphical explanation of IRON DOME and the missile threat. http://www.defenceforumindia.com

 

The Israeli ‘Iron Dome’ weapons system is a theatre air defence system employed by the Israeli Defence Forces for the detection and interception of inbound hostile weapons (short range rockets, artillery shells and mortars) being directed against the state of Israel. Iron Dome claims a spectacularly high success rate, yet some of the figures are open to interpretation. For instance of the 200+ rockets which were fired against Israel since the start of the recent barrage, only between one-third and one-quarter had actually been intercepted. The IDF claims that they only intercepted rockets headed for built up areas; rockets deemed to be headed for uninhabited areas were allowed through. The interceptor battery system itself is an expensive operation; each Tamir interceptor missile costs between €35-50,000 (even an Upgraded GRAD costs less than $1500). The entire system’s pricetag runs into the billion dollar mark, largely picked up by the US government. Whether or not Israel could afford an independent system, is highly questionable, as is its ability to hit the target every time.

 

A Tamir interceptor missile being launched from an IRON DOME battery. Each Battery can theoretically defence up to 150km of residential area.

A Tamir interceptor missile being launched from an IRON DOME battery. Each Battery can theoretically defence up to 150km of residential area.

 

Realistically, the Iron Dome will be stretched to breaking point should the Palestinians decide to target an urban Israeli area with a co-ordinated and sustained barrage of projectiles. Iron Dome works best when employed against individual rockets. When (not if) the Palestinians go back to using the GRAD and its sister systems against Jerusalem, Tel Aviv or Haifa, in a conventional massed attack, then it is my belief that the flaws in the Israeli futuristic defensive strategy will be exposed by Cold War technology.

 

Criticism of the Iron Dome system 

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-21751766

Posted in Cold War, Conflict, Insurgency, Palestine, Soviet, United States | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Remember the Alamo?

theobservor.com blog

Phil Collins discussing his fascination with the Alamo and his decision to donate his extensive colelction of material to the public. theobservor.com blog

Phil Collins donates Alamo hoard http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-28054287

Collection of military memorabilia is at an all time. With the natural rise in interest in the First World War with the centenary of that conflict rapidly approaching. In this case it’s Phil Collins and his interest/obsession with the Battle of the Alamo, the thirteen day-siege of the Alamo Mission by the forces of Mexican President Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna, which culminated in a final devastating attack on March 6th, 1836. This doomed heroism provoked the ire of Texans, who rose up in defiance of Santa Anna’s regime and flocked to the army of General Sam Houston. Collins has confessed to having a massive obsession with the era and the climactic events of the Alamo, even going as far as to write the 2008 book The Alamo and Beyond: A Collectors Journey which details his engrossment; he even bought a neighbouring building and excavated down 44 inches to ‘battle depth’ in order to uncover further artefacts! He claims his interest was piqued during a visit to an antique shop during a tour, where he saw an extant letter and was later given a receipt for a saddle which one of the Alamo courier riders had received. This present from his third wife helped to fan the flames on what would become a lifelong love affair with the battle.

Interests are healthy things. For instance I have an interest in military matters, as expressed through the medium of this blog; a weekly diary entry of my thoughts on the interactions of the history of Warfare with our modern world, if you will. For others, especially the “amateur” historians, or the collector in the street, with their own interests and their own specific collections, history can become quite focused. The narrow focus on a battle or a conflict or a unit/collection of unit flashes, can lead to too narrow a focus sometimes. Which can in turn lead to the exclusion of the macro in favour of the narrower micro. While collectors often value a select few ‘prize’ items with a direct connection to their favourite event/period over others, they should exercise caution so that this is not to the detriment of their view of the larger period. An item of ephemera or a uniform/weapon is only truly valuable when it is viewed as being part of the greater historical tapestry.

war_2783649b

Great War reenactor

At the same time private collections can secure treasure troves for the state or locality which is often (rightly or wrongly) hard pressed to purchase items which might come up at auction. The Jackie Clarke collection, which is housed the old Provincial Bank building in Ballina, Mayo, Rep. of Ireland, is a great example. Jackie Clarke, a local man, amassed an amazing collection of items which range over four-hundred years of British and Irish history; items in the collection include an edition of the Oxford Gazette dated from 1665, reputed to be the first newspaper, copies of the 1916 and 1917 Proclamation of the Irish Republic and letters from Irish military hero Michael Collins, Irish President Douglas Hyde, land reformer and folk hero Michael Davitt and the infamous Fenian leader O’Donovan Rossa, to name but a few.

17JPJACKIE1-articleLarge

Sinead McCoole, archivist of the Jackie Clarke Collection in Ballina, Mayo. Most of the items were uncatalogued and were wrapped in old newspapers, or plain brown paper packages with string. nytimes.com

While collections as deep and as rich as these are rare, when donated to the public, they offer an unrivalled view into the past for all who care to gaze upon them. But they are not without their detractors in some quarters who feel that they are an extravagance and a ‘poisoned chalice’ on the grounds that the government under which they are operating will never make a ha’penny [sic halfpenny] out of exhibiting and curating our cultural heritage. This mindset is thankfully not replicated too widely, but there are still those out there in and out of positions of power who feel that cherishing our shared cultural heritage is not a job for the state.

irishgreatwarsociety.com reenactors

Reenactors of the Irish Great War Society practice a casualty evacuation. Note the highly accurate uniforms and trappings

The tireless work and investment by archivists, passionate reenactors, collectors, even hoarders if you will, allows historians a rich tranche of material with which to work from to help modern society construct a more cohesive narrative of our shared cultural heritage. The archivist is the quartermaster to the historian in the cut and thrust in the establishment of the narrative. The actions of Collins, Clarke, et al to not only collect at their own expense, but to actively and consciously fight to return their private treasures to the public sphere, speaks volumes regarding the esteem in which these collectors hold their items. If you will think for a second of the single most valuable item you own, treasure more than anything else, something you’ve spent a lifetime collecting and caring for; now give it away to the whole world, for free and let them all gaze upon something you have kept to yourself for so long. Those are the actions of a true scholar.

To end as I started, I’ll reference the great Mr. Collins, whilst adding that even though he wasn’t talking explicitly about historians, the lyrics to That’s Just the Way It Is can still resonate in this context… ‘Cos all day long he was fighting for you/And he didn’t even know your name/Young men come and young men go/But life goes on just the same.’

    External Links   http://www.rollingstone.com/music/news/phil-collins-donates-collection-of-200-alamo-artifacts-20140626   http://www.nydailynews.com/entertainment/phil-collins-donates-alamo-artifacts-article-1.1846660   http://www.clarkecollection.ie/Collection/   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ar9aPpQeIdo

Posted in Archive, Commemoration, Conflict, Empire, Memory, United States | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment